Free shipping on orders $35+ | Afterpay available at checkout | Order online or 800-935-1935

Collection: Gifts under $25

149 products
  • Birthstone Stackable Vintage Ring
    Birthstone Stackable Vintage Ring Birthstone Stackable Vintage Ring
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $17.00 USD
  • Vintage Exotic Bee Pins P5280
    Vintage Exotic Bee Pins P5280 Vintage Exotic Bee Pins P5280
    Regular price
    $22.00 USD
    Sale price
    $20.00 USD
  • Inspirational Message Bar Bangle Bracelets
    Inspirational Message Bar Bangle Bracelets Inspirational Message Bar Bangle Bracelets
    Regular price
    $28.00 USD
    Sale price
    $25.20 USD
  • Meowy Catmas Christmas Pin
    Meowy Catmas Christmas Pin Meowy Catmas Christmas Pin
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.00 USD
  • Multi Aurora Crystal Heart Earrings E975
    Multi Aurora Crystal Heart Earrings E975 Multi Aurora Crystal Heart Earrings E975
    Regular price
    $32.00 USD
    Sale price
    $28.80 USD
  • Keep the Faith Tiny Crosses Layering Necklace N1320
    Keep the Faith Tiny Crosses Layering Necklace N1320 Keep the Faith Tiny Crosses Layering Necklace N1320-GO
    Regular price
    $22.00 USD
    Sale price
    $19.80 USD
  • Keep the Faith Tiny Crosses Earrings E1321
    Keep the Faith Tiny Crosses Earrings E1321 Keep the Faith Tiny Crosses Earrings E1321
    Regular price
    $13.00 USD
    Sale price
    $11.70 USD
  • Moon & Stars Earrings E1398
    Moon & Stars Earrings E1398 Moon & Stars Earrings E1398
    Regular price
    $22.00 USD
    Sale price
    $19.80 USD
  • Lord's Prayer Pendant Necklace N1242
    Lord's Prayer Pendant Necklace N1242 Lord's Prayer Pendant Necklace N1242
    Regular price
    $22.00 USD
    Sale price
    $19.80 USD
  • Swarovski Crystal Solitaire Birthstone Pendant Necklace
    Swarovski Crystal Solitaire Birthstone Pendant Necklace Swarovski Crystal Solitaire Birthstone Pendant Necklace
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.00 USD
  • Premium Preciosa Crystal Dainty Birthstone Earrings
    Premium Preciosa Crystal Dainty Birthstone Earrings Swarovski Crystal Dainty Birthstone Earrings
    Regular price
    $21.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.90 USD
  • Beaded Bracelet
    Something Fishy Bead Bracelet BR1202 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Beaded Bracelet
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.00 USD
  • Marquis Filigree Layering Necklace N1317
    Marquis Filigree Layering Necklace N1317 Marquis Filigree Layering Necklace N1317
    Regular price
    $32.00 USD
    Sale price
    $28.05 USD
  • Elvira's Poison Bottles
    Elvira's Poison Bottles Elvira's Poison Bottles
    Regular price
    $29.00 USD
    Sale price
    $25.10 USD
  • Bee Pin P665
    Bee Hat Pin P665 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Bee Pin P665
    Regular price
    $18.00 USD
    Sale price
    $16.20 USD
  • Primroses Flower Barrette B169
    Primroses Flower Barrette B169 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Primroses Flower Barrette B169
    Regular price
    $14.00 USD
    Sale price
    $12.60 USD
  • Cat Pin P667
    Cat Pin P667 Cat Pin P667
    Regular price
    $15.00 USD
    Sale price
    $13.50 USD
  • Elvira's Poison Bottle - Love
    Elvira's Poison Bottle - Love NEW! Limited Edition Elvira's Poison Bottles - Love - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    Regular price
    $29.00 USD
    Sale price
    $25.10 USD
  • Faith Can Work Miracles Pendant Necklace N1252
    Faith Can Work Miracles Pendant Necklace N1252 Faith Can Work Miracles Pendant Necklace N1252
    Regular price
    $24.00 USD
    Sale price
    $21.60 USD
  • Dog Lover Necklaces
    Dog Lover Necklaces Dog Lover Necklaces
    Regular price
    $19.00 USD
    Sale price
    $17.10 USD
  • Cat Lover Necklaces
    Cat Lover Necklaces Cat Lover Necklaces
    Regular price
    $19.00 USD
    Sale price
    $17.10 USD
  • Kitty Valentine Pin P332
    Kitty Valentine Pin P332 Kitty Valentine Pin P332
    Regular price
    $18.00 USD
    Sale price
    $16.20 USD
  • Twin Kittens Vintage Pin P680
    Twin Kittens Vintage Pin P680 Twin Kittens Vintage Pin P680
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $15.30 USD
  • Elvira's Poison Bottle - Peace
    NEW! Limited Edition Elvira's Poison Bottles - Love - sweetromanceonlinejewelry NEW! Limited Edition Elvira's Poison Bottles - Love - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    Regular price
    $29.00 USD
    Sale price
    $25.10 USD
  • Little Girls Heart Locket Necklace
    Little Girls Heart Locket Necklace Little Girls Heart Locket Necklace
    Regular price
    $21.00 USD
    Sale price
    $17.30 USD
  • Caged Beads Retro Layering Necklace N1318
    Caged Beads Retro Layering Necklace N1318 Caged Beads Retro Layering Necklace N1318
    Regular price
    $19.00 USD
    Sale price
    $17.10 USD
  • Deco Starburst X Pin P655
    Deco Starburst X Hat Pin P655 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Deco Starburst X Hat Pin P655 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    Regular price
    $24.00 USD
    Sale price
    $21.60 USD
  • Little Enamel Easter Egg Earrings E201
    Little Enamel Easter Egg Earrings E201 Little Enamel Easter Egg Earrings E201
    Regular price
    $15.00 USD
    Sale price
    $13.50 USD
  • Baguette Bobby Pins P302
    Baguette Bobby Pins BP302 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Baguette Bobby Pins BP302 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    Regular price
    $18.00 USD
    Sale price
    $16.20 USD
  • French Rose Glass Ring R536
    French Jet and Rose Glass Ring French Rose Glass Ring R536
    Regular price
    $34.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.60 USD
  • Fleur de Lis Paris Enamel Pin P660
    Fleur de Lis Paris Enamel Pin P660 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Fleur de Lis Paris Enamel Pin P660 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    Regular price
    $18.00 USD
    Sale price
    $16.20 USD
  • Hermosa Beach beads Seashell Necklace N1367
    Hermosa Beach beads Seashell Necklace N1367 Hermosa Beach beads Seashell Necklace N1367 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.00 USD
  • Raven Halloween Pin
    Raven Halloween Pin Raven Halloween Pin
    Regular price
    $18.00 USD
    Sale price
    $16.20 USD
  • Queen of Hearts Ring R537
    Queen of Hearts Ring Queen of Hearts Ring
    Regular price
    $34.00 USD
    Sale price
    $30.60 USD
  • Santa & Rudolf Christmas Pin
    Santa & Rudolf Christmas Pin Santa & Rudolf Christmas Pin
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.00 USD
  • I Love You Even More Today Pendant Necklace N1251
    I Love You Even More Today Pendant Necklace N1251 I Love You Even More Today Pendant Necklace N1251
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.00 USD
  • Elvira's Poison Bottle - Abundance
    NEW! Limited Edition Elvira's Poison Bottles - Abundance - sweetromanceonlinejewelry NEW! Limited Edition Elvira's Poison Bottles - Abundance - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    Regular price
    $29.00 USD
    Sale price
    $25.10 USD
  • Petite Square Earrings
    Petite Square Earrings Petite Square Earrings
    Regular price
    $12.00 USD
    Sale price
    $10.80 USD
  • Boho Crystals & Beads Headpiece
    Boho Crystals & Beads Headpiece Boho Crystals & Beads Headpiece
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.00 USD
  • Dragonfly Pin P675
    Dragonfly Pin P675 Dragonfly Pin P675
    Regular price
    $22.00 USD
    Sale price
    $19.80 USD
  • Compass Pin P668
    Compass Pin P668 Compass Hat Pin P668 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.00 USD
  • Ladybug Toe Ring
    Ladybug Toe Ring Ladybug Toe Ring
    Regular price
    $11.00 USD
    Sale price
    $9.90 USD
  • Elvira's Poison Bottle - Healing
    NEW! Limited Edition Elvira's Poison Bottles - Healing - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Elvira's Poison Bottle - Healing
    Regular price
    $29.00 USD
    Sale price
    $25.10 USD
  • Delicate Dainty Star Earrings E1496
    Delicate Dainty Star Earrings E1496 Delicate Dainty Star Earrings E1496
    Regular price
    $19.00 USD
    Sale price
    $17.10 USD
  • Zodiac Earrings E1241
    Zodiac Earrings Zodiac Earrings E1241
    Regular price
    $24.00 USD
    Sale price
    $21.60 USD
  • Airplane Propeller and Gear Steampunk Charm Necklace N318
    Airplane Propeller and Gear Steampunk Charm Necklace N318 Airplane Propeller and Gear Steampunk Charm Necklace N318
    Regular price
    $21.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.90 USD
  • Bat Pin P681
    Bat Pin P681 Bat Pin P681 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    Regular price
    $18.00 USD
    Sale price
    $16.20 USD
  • Crystal Hearts Earrings E337
    Crystal Hearts Earrings E337 Crystal Hearts Earrings E337
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.00 USD
  • Sword Pin P676
    Sword Pin P676 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Sword Pin P676 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    Regular price
    $24.00 USD
    Sale price
    $21.60 USD
  • Photo Box Necklace N316
    Photo Box Necklace N316 Photo Box Necklace N316
    Regular price
    $20.00 USD
    Sale price
    $18.00 USD