Free shipping on orders $35+ | Afterpay available at checkout | Order online or 800-935-1935

Gifts under $25

143 products
  • NEW! Limited Edition Elvira's Poison Bottles - Power - sweetromanceonlinejewelry NEW! Limited Edition Elvira's Poison Bottles - Power - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $28.00 USD
    $28.00 USD
  • Tree of Life Necklace N1236 Tree of Life Necklace N1236
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
  • Lizard Pin P664 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Lizard Pin P664
    $17.00 USD
    $15.30 USD
  • Enamel Baby Frog Pin Enamel Baby Frog Pin
    $24.00 USD
    $21.70 USD
  • Vintage Vixens Comic Rings Vintage Vixens Comic Rings
    $20.00 USD
    $18.00 USD
  • Halo Hoop Earrings - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Halo Hoop Earrings
    $23.00 USD
    $23.00 USD
  • Hi there Valentine' Puppy Valentine Pin P349 Hi there Valentine' Puppy Valentine Pin P349
    $16.20 USD
    $16.20 USD
  • Rainbow Flower Vintage Earrings E945 Rainbow Flower Vintage Earrings E945
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
  • Caduceus Serpent Pin P670 Caduceus Serpent Pin P670
    $24.00 USD
    $21.60 USD
  • Mischievous Victorian Monkey Pin P679 Mischievous Monkey w/ Crystal Pin P679 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $17.00 USD
    $15.30 USD
  • Double Stone Crystal Stud Earrings Double Stone Crystal Stud Earrings E1247
    $22.00 USD
    $22.00 USD
  • Skinny Stacking Cuff Bracelet Sweet Romance BR530 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Skinny Stacking Cuff Bracelet Sweet Romance BR530 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $26.00 USD
    $26.00 USD
  • Leaf Crown Bobby Pins Leaf Crown Bobby Pins
    $16.00 USD
    $14.40 USD
  • Swarovski Crystal Dainty Teardrop Earrings Swarovski Crystal Dainty Teardrop Earrings
    $24.00 USD
    $24.00 USD
  • Dog Pin P682 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Dog Pin P682
    $15.00 USD
    $13.50 USD
  • Pistol Gun Pin P678 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Pistol Gun Pin P678 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $18.00 USD
    $16.20 USD
  • Speak no, See no, Hear no evil Monkey Brooch P661 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Speak no, See no, Hear no evil Monkey Brooch P661 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $16.00 USD
    $14.05 USD
  • Cross Toe Ring Cross Toe Ring
    $11.00 USD
    $9.90 USD
  • Skull & Crossbones Pin P653 Skull & Crossbones Pin P653
    $18.00 USD
    $16.20 USD
  • Victorian Valentine Cherub Earrings E161-P Victorian Valentine Cherub Earrings E161-P
    $22.00 USD
    $22.00 USD
  • Roses Valentine Pin P350 - 50% OFF!! Roses Valentine Pin P350 - 50% OFF!!
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
  • Inverted Crescent Moon Earrings E1503 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Inverted Crescent Moon Earrings E1503 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
  • Star Bangle Bracelet BR545 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Star Bangle Bracelet BR545 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
  • NEW! Limited Edition Elvira's Poison Bottles - Intuition - sweetromanceonlinejewelry NEW! Limited Edition Elvira's Poison Bottles - Intuition - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $28.00 USD
    $28.00 USD
  • Puffy Heart Toe Ring Puffy Heart Toe Ring
    $11.00 USD
    $9.90 USD
  • Victorian Flower Toe Ring Victorian Flower Toe Ring
    $11.00 USD
    $9.90 USD
  • Creepy Spider Pin P651 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Creepy Spider Pin P651 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $20.00 USD
    $17.05 USD
  • Vintage Crystal Flower Ring Vintage Crystal Flower Ring
    $15.00 USD
    $15.00 USD
  • Pegasus Ring Pegasus Ring
    $34.00 USD
    $30.60 USD
  • Be My Valentine' Valentine Pin P345 Be My Valentine' Valentine Pin P345
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
  • Ocean Spirits Charm Necklace Ocean Spirits Charm Necklace N1548
    $39.00 USD
    $39.00 USD
  • Seahorse Ocean Necklace Seahorse Ocean Necklace
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
  • Lizette 2 Tier Necklace Lizette 2 Tier Necklace
    $59.00 USD
    $59.00 USD
  • Lucky Horseshoe Birthstone Necklace N1238 Lucky Horseshoe Birthstone Necklace N1238
    $17.00 USD
    $17.00 USD
  • Round Pearl Drop Earrings E572-OL Round Pearl Drop Earrings E572-OL
    $24.00 USD
    $24.00 USD
  • Retro Modern Millefiori Glass Drop Earrings E548 Retro Modern Millefiori Glass Drop Earrings E548
    $12.00 USD
    $12.00 USD
  • Half Hoop Crystal Earrings Half Hoop Crystal Earrings
    $32.00 USD
    $32.00 USD
  • Cherub Doorknocker Clip-On Earrings E161-C Cherub Doorknocker Clip-On Earrings E161-C
    $25.00 USD
    $25.00 USD
  • Thin Crystal Bar Earrings Thin Crystal Bar Earrings
    $14.00 USD
    $14.00 USD
  • Jet Black Earrings E0319 Jet Black Earrings E0319
    $5.00 USD
    $5.00 USD
  • Airplane Hat Pin P677 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Airplane Hat Pin P677 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $17.05 USD
    $17.05 USD
  • Tiny Charm Necklaces - Bronze Tiny Charm Necklaces - Bronze
    $20.00 USD
    $20.00 USD
  • Crescent Moon Pin P674 Crescent Moon Hat Pin P674 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $22.00 USD
    $22.00 USD
  • Circle Charm Layering Necklace N1314 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Circle Charm Layering Necklace N1314 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $29.00 USD
    $29.00 USD
  • Fleur de Lis Hat Pin P673 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Fleur de Lis Hat Pin P673 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $20.00 USD
    $18.00 USD
  • Summer Flower Toe Ring and Finger Ring Summer Flower Toe Ring and Finger Ring
    $11.00 USD
    $9.90 USD
  • Pair of Dice P672 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Pair of Dice P672 - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $22.00 USD
    $19.80 USD
  • Dainty Vintage Cat Necklace - sweetromanceonlinejewelry Dainty Vintage Cat Necklace - sweetromanceonlinejewelry
    $26.00 USD
    $26.00 USD
  • Love Letters' Valentine Pin P344 Love Letters' Valentine Pin P344
    $16.20 USD
    $16.20 USD
  • Flying Swallow Pin P671 Flying Swallow Pin P671
    $26.00 USD
    $23.40 USD